Quantcast
Jump to content

Can a one man shop make it today?


Recommended Posts

So like the thread title says, can a one man shop make it in todays competitive marketplace? How many others on here are a one man shop?

 

I've been considering opening up my own place like so many others, but I don't want to deal with HR issues, nor the stress of having to find work to keep employees busy right off the bat when starting up.

 

Can one person do all the business stuff, service writing and wrenching, and still turn a profit?

 

Thanks,

Kevo

Link to comment
Share on other sites



So like the thread title says, can a one man shop make it in todays competitive marketplace?  How many others on here are a one man shop?

 

I've been considering opening up my own place like so many others, but I don't want to deal with HR issues, nor the stress of having to find work to keep employees busy right off the bat when starting up.

 

Can one person do all the business stuff, service writing and wrenching, and still turn a profit?

 

Thanks,

Kevo

It's a lot to do! It's possible but easy to get burnt out. We're a three person shop, a tech a helper and a counter person.

 

 

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So those of you that ran as a one man shop for a while, what kind of hours did you work versus the amount of labor you actually billed out? I was thinking in an 8-9hr day I'd probably only be able to bill out 6hrs if lucky.

 

Kevo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been a one man shop for two years, it's been challenging but also rewarding and very profitable. My biggest problem is interuptions, answering the phone and waiting on walk in traffic. On busy days makes it hard to get work done. Still though I manage to bill 6 or more hours nearly everyday(flat rate), plus parts and accessories sales(besides auto repair I'm also a trailer shop and sell lots of parts). My other problem has been overbooking. I'm getting better at that though. I'm typically booked out a week, but I try to leave some slack time on certain days if possible for my own sanity, the job that runs long and those emergency repair situations.

 

Don't know how long I can hang on by myself nor how long I want to. It's a lot of work and I'm 51 now. I've been trying to avoid getting into payrol, you know work comp, taxes, 941's. I had another business for 25 years with 4 - 6 guys working so I know the drill and am trying to keep it simple this time.

 

So yes, a one man shop can make it, but be prepared to work hard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 man shop bill out 6 hours a day??? Not consistently, no way. 

Exactly, not in general repair. As mentioned above a specialty shop that just does something like brakes or trailer work its much easier to turn more hours. Not to mention shop clean up and paperwork may take one full day.

 

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do plan to try to specialize somewhat, but at first to keep the doors open I figured it would be good to remain flexible and do a much as possible.

 

My main interest is offroad 4x4 fabrication and suspension design. Unfortunately, its a niche market thats hard to find people willing to spend the big $$$ to have something that works well. I currently do some fabrication out of my home shop, but its not a legitimate business and I have no insurance for it either. Its sketchy to say the least! I need a real shop and business license!

 

I figure by being flexible and doing general repair work I can at least pay the bills the first year. That will allow me to get my name out there and get established. With a resale license I can also start selling offroad parts, lockers, lift kits, lights, and with a shop I can install those parts.

 

I also want to start doing driveshaft repair. This goes along quite well with the 4x4 shop theme. Every 4x4 has two shafts, and everytime you change the suspension or drivetrain they both must be modified. The only driveshaft shop locally is 45min away in another town and they don't understand whats needed for offroad shafts. I had a friend who did this for awhile and allways seemed busy. His downfall was his divorce. He also did a lot of shaft work for local farmers.

 

So yes eventually I would like to specialize somewhat. Depending on how busy things get I think I might hire also, but for now I need to keep things simple and just see if I can get it off the ground. I'll have to look into the trailer idea, thats not a bad idea around here and could go along with the offroad truck theme rather well.

 

Thanks for the input!

Kevo

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am a one man shop. Been open since 2004. I have had times when I bring in helpers, mostly my son. Shop opens at 8 am and I have worked as late as midnight if the work is here. Generally I try to close by 6 pm. 2-3 nights a week I do paper work. I have been slacking but I try to spend a few hours a week on keeping up on the Facebook post and changing up the marketing to keep it fresh. I took off last weekend, first time in over a month. I am not married and my son is 34, so no real home life.

Without pulling all the reports I would guess I avg 4 hours billable in an 8 hour day. I have very low overhead compared to others but it is still a struggle. And just for reference I am 56 and have been in the trade since 1985 or so.

The biggest problem is scheduling work and hitting promise times. I also have been taking in some "project" type work. It is good for filling the slow days but gets in the way when busy. Right now I have a 1987 Grand National that had the engine pulled over 2 years ago.It sat at another shop till the owner became ill. Now I am restoring it to running condition, then off to the body shop. Also have a 93 vette with a dead short in the power seats. And finally a 2003 F350 6.0 for injectors (my first).

 

It hasn't been easy but I have managed to get by. I have quit, come back and threatened too quit again. The rewards can be huge but the stress can kill ya!!

I started out .. 30 or so years ago, by myself. Then one helper, then two, then three, then apprentices and more help. The shop got huge. I was working more hours than I did when I started out. Sure, I made a good paycheck but the stress was unbearable. When the economy tanked years ago guys moved on and I didn't replace them. Now, in the last 5 years I've been by myself with my daughter handling the phones. It has been a blessing in disguise. I go home when I want, I work as late as I want, and I have the weekends for myself and family.

 

Personally, I prefer doing the work myself. No payroll to speak of, no comebacks, and little to no stress. Quite a difference than when I ran the shop with a big crew. Yes, I don't make as much, but I make enough. Can't say I'd ever go back to a full crew again. Ain't happening.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gonzo- I did not know you were a one man shop. Your reasons for staying small are a lot of the reasons I want to stay small too,....basicly being able to control the stress end of things better.

 

Having time to think about things though I realize how difficult that is to stay a one man shop, and there are benefits to having people work for you. It might be better in the long run to have 2 techs and a service writer that handle the auto repairs, then I can be in the background doing more specialized tasks. Either that or try to specialize right at the start.

 

Kevo

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 man operation is very stressful but yes you can make money. If all you want is to,own a JOB with a lil freedom then its the way to go. If you want a BUSINESS that makes money even if you're not there then you need qualified Help. Just depends on your retirement plans. I say go for the gold. Build a biz so you can work 1 day week if you choose.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gonzo- I did not know you were a one man shop. Your reasons for staying small are a lot of the reasons I want to stay small too,....basicly being able to control the stress end of things better.

 

Having time to think about things though I realize how difficult that is to stay a one man shop, and there are benefits to having people work for you. It might be better in the long run to have 2 techs and a service writer that handle the auto repairs, then I can be in the background doing more specialized tasks. Either that or try to specialize right at the start.

 

Kevo

I've been big, and the stress of being bigger was the key to getting small again. I can work 1 day a week or 7. Next to no stress these days. My bays stay full and I stay busy. My wife put it best, "You work the shop...don't let the shop work you!" If your goal is to make the shop into something more than the one man shop...all the power in the world to you. I prefer the one man shop and at my age I don't see me changing. I think ... if you're bold enough .... do the BIG shop. It might be just what you want.

 

Right now, if I'm called to go to a convention, I just close the doors for a few days. Ya'd think my customers would object, actually the opposite. The more classes I attend the better I am at servicing their cars. And, they appreciate that.

 

All in all, it's a decision you have to make for yourself. I made mine and no regrets about it.

 

Good luck! Happy wrenchin! Gonzo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been big, and the stress of being bigger was the key to getting small again. I can work 1 day a week or 7. Next to no stress these days. My bays stay full and I stay busy. My wife put it best, "You work the shop...don't let the shop work you!" If your goal is to make the shop into something more than the one man shop...all the power in the world to you. I prefer the one man shop and at my age I don't see me changing. I think ... if you're bold enough .... do the BIG shop. It might be just what you want.

 

Right now, if I'm called to go to a convention, I just close the doors for a few days. Ya'd think my customers would object, actually the opposite. The more classes I attend the better I am at servicing their cars. And, they appreciate that.

 

All in all, it's a decision you have to make for yourself. I made mine and no regrets about it.

 

Good luck! Happy wrenchin! Gonzo

I often wonder what the consequences would be for locking the doors for a couple days. Being a one man shop I never get a day off, except for Sundays, although sometimes I will take a Saturday off. Or what if I get sick and just can't come in? Nice to hear your customers are OK with you shutting down occasionally.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am a one man army who occasionally brings in help. THE TRICK is knowing when to say no. Some people are afraid to say no to certain jobs because they think they will lose the customer. I regularly turn down jobs because of complexity and when you wear many hats every day, it becomes stressful. The most profitable way is to do more small jobs like brake and suspension work, and less big jobs like engine replacements. The big jobs pay big but often take a week or more to complete because you are juggling jobs. The smaller jobs have larger profit margins like brakes, maintenance and such. I would rather do 5 brake jobs a wee than two tranny swaps.

 

Many times i tell a customer no due to the complexity and keep it simple but usually have a recommendation on where they can go. Then they usually come back for the other stuff. When a customer is low on money, you have to stop feeling bad for them and stop trying to be the hero. then you get involved in junk work that they want used parts and such. Tell then ahead of time what it costs or MAY end up costing and if they go away, then good cause that is less headache.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kevo,

 

Yes a one-man shop can make it. I've been doing it for nearly two years. But, there is a catch; I have part-time help. More and more I'm going with 5-day weeks, and even closing my doors for a day's vacation.

 

As others mentioned, you need to be aware of your own limits on how much stress you can take. Screen the jobs, at least when you are busy. When you are slow you can afford to do the less desirable jobs.

 

My experience has been that customers feel safer dealing directly with the owner/technician. It's a real handful to do most everything yourself but very rewarding! After all, we didn't choose this occupation to just loaf around, but to meet the challenges of the automotive repair world!

 

So I give you my best wishes and if I can help you out anytime, let me know. Looks like we are geographically not too far apart.

Regards,

Jon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been thinking about this quite a bit lately. I feel if you have a strong customer base already established a one man shop can do great and make a lot of money with not too much stress. Ideally a one man shop is never "open" to the public, but rather a customer calls your cell phone and you do the job, maybe have an independent contractor type helper. No waiting room, no sign, just an anonymous shop. Ideally it would be at your house so you can share the utilities. I am talking about a legit shop, not a backyard evader. In NY they allow these types of simple shops, some states don't. Cash only. A shop like this can do just 10% of the work of a 5 man shop and make the same profit. The downside is 1. you have to do all the work, 2. you really can't sell this type of business and 3. it would be hard to attract new customers. Like someone said you are just giving yourself a job which isn't necessarily a bad thing.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always thought I was in the minority on here, being a 1 man shop, but it appers there are quite a few who have also found it to be possible...maybe even satisfying as well. I think all of the pros and cons have been adequately described. I must say that my wife does a GREAT job of handling the front when the kids are in school, (answering phones, greeting customers, ordering parts, collecting payment, etc.) and that is a HUGE advantage that I miss dearly when she's out for the summer months. She does allow me to concentrate on getting repairs diagnosed and done PROPERLY, which is something that was more work for me to achieve when I had (2) guys in the shop. SO many variables that will effect this question, but it CAN be done and a modest living generated from it.

 

Great topic. Very interesting/encouraging to hear others situations.

 

Dwayne

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Have you checked out Joe's Latest Blog?

         1 comment
      Have I got your attention? Great.
      Let me start by saying that I believe in giving praise when deserved and letting employees know when they dropped the ball. However, the truth is that no one enjoys being reprimanded or told they messed up.  
      The question is, what is the appropriate balance between the right amount of praise and the right amount of critical feedback? According to studies done by Harvard Business School, the ratio of praise to critical feedback should be about 6:1 – Six praises for every critical feedback. I am not sure if I agree with that.
      From personal experience, I would recommend a lot more praise. The exact ratio doesn’t matter. What’s important is that before you consider giving critical feedback, ensure you have given that employee a lot of recent praise. If not, whatever you are trying to get through to an employee, will fall on deaf ears.
      When you do have to give critical feedback, remember a few things:
      Focus on the issue or behavior; never attack the person, and remain calm in your actions and words Ask the employee for feedback, their side of the story Speak to the employee in private Address the issue soon after it happens; never wait Don’t rely on second-hand information; it’s always better if you have experienced the situation yourself that you want to correct Have an open discussion and find things that both of you can agree upon Have an action plan moving forward that the employee can take ownership of Use the experience as a learning tool Make sure you bring up positive attributes about them Remember, you don’t want the employee to be angry or upset with you; you want them to reflect on the situation and what can be improved. One last thing. Everyone makes mistakes. We need to be mindful of this.
  • Similar Topics

    • By Joe Marconi
      Many auto repair shops are still busy, and many are booked out from a few days to weeks.  After the initial shock of Covid, the recovery for our independent auto repair industry has been quite good, with many positive indicators for the future.
      However, how many of the auto repair shops that did suffer a great loss in business during the lockdown phase of Covid would have survived if not for the SBA loans, the Pay Protection Program and the Employee Retention Credit?  
      Building a cash reserve is crucial to prepare yourself for the next economic downturn.  How much should you set aside?  That depends on your business model, how much debt you have and other financial conditions.  Speak to your accountant, financial advisor and business coach, if you have one. 
      Rule of thumb, you should have at least three months of operating expenses set aside in a dedicated bank account.  Some accountants and financial advisors may suggest up to six months. 
    • By ASOG Podcast
      The Biggest Mistake New Shops Make
    • By carmcapriotto
      Recorded Live at the 2023 Institute Summit, shop owner turned coach Jennifer Hulbert discusses the value of joining a coaching group. Find out what it's like to be in a coaching group with the Institute, and why she is passionate about celebrating other people's accomplishments.
      Jennifer Hulbert, Service Plus Automotive, Calcium, NY. Facilitator for the Institute for Automotive Business Excellence.
      Show Notes
      Has 3 coaching clients- discovering finances, gross profit, structuring segments of business, increasing billable hours, and implementing a parts matrix. Facilitating- a group usually consists of 18 to 20 shop owners. They are assigned a partner, they have an individual accountability partner along with access to their facilitator coach. Have three in-person meetings a year. Part of those in-person meetings is to evaluate the whole shop. Go in,  do a full evaluation of the shop, and give the owner feedback on areas for improvement. The other time is spent with training, and reviewing financial numbers, because if you don't know your numbers, you're never going to grow your business. In between, they have a couple of Zoom meetings as an entire group, and then the facilitator does reach out individually once a month.  Never be the smartest person in the room If you’re not learning, you’re not growing Celebrate other people's accomplishments Joining a coaching company- understand profits, understand the structure of a business, understand your numbers, and structure your finances to make a profit.  “Mama Bear of the Team”- Jennifer wants to see individual employees and their families succeed. Ensuring whatever decision you are making about the company is going to benefit your employees Women can do anything that a man can do Read the book “Traction: Get a Grip on Your Business”- communicate clear goals, build a leadership team, and hold each other accountable. Increased sales by 38% 
      Thanks to our Partner, NAPA AUTO CARE Learn more about NAPA AUTO CARE and the benefits of being part of the NAPA family by visiting www.NAPAAutoCare.com Connect with the Podcast: -Join our Insider List: https://remarkableresults.biz/insider -All books mentioned on our podcasts: https://remarkableresults.biz/books -Our Classroom page for personal or team learning: https://remarkableresults.biz/classroom -Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/carm -The Aftermarket Radio Network: https://aftermarketradionetwork.com -Special episode collections: https://remarkableresults.biz/collections
         
      Click to go to the Podcast on Remarkable Results Radio
    • By ASOG Podcast
      Opening a Shop? Don't Make This Critical Mistake!
    • By carmcapriotto
      During Today's episode #104 The crew from SMP and I Talk About:
      What is a Chicken Flicker? Behind-the-scenes dirt on Kim & Brian from SMP What's the best part of your work day? What's the difference between a successful client and one that isn't? What would your advice be for a shop starting out that isn't able to hire someone like SMP? How cute is Dutton? Favorite Cartoon Character? What did you want to be when you grew up? What book are you reading now, if any?  
      This episode is sponsored by AutoLeap. AutoLeap is a cloud-based all-in-one automotive invoice software that helps you supercharge your mechanic shop. Their customers have experienced:
       
      30% increase in revenue by improving transparency and trust 50% reduction in time spent researching and ordering parts 10% increase in profit margins through robust reporting  
      Click here to learn more about AutoLeap and schedule a demo: http://bit.ly/3GRgO88
       
      Don't forget to rate and review us!
      Connect with Chris:
      [email protected]
      940.400.1008
      www.autoshopcoaching.com
      Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AutoFixAutoShopCoaching
      Youtube: https://bit.ly/3ClX0ae
      Click to go to the Podcast on Remarkable Results Radio


  • Our Sponsors



×
×
  • Create New...