Jump to content

Joe Marconi

My Wall Street Journal Interview

Recommended Posts



Mechanics Seek Out 'Right to Repair'




When independent mechanic Joe Marconi replaced a faulty windshield-wiper switch last summer on a 2004 Saab—a minor type of repair often done at his shop—the car wouldn't start.


Mr. Marconi, who owns Osceola Garage in Baldwin Place, N.Y., discovered the switch needed to be "initialized," something only a Saab dealership can do. Initializing is a problem that has been happening more and more often, says the 55-year-old mechanic.


"The entire car basically has to be reprogrammed to accept the new part," he says. In the end, he was forced to pass the vehicle, and his customer, on to the dealer.


As auto makers design vehicles with increasingly sophisticated technology, independent mechanics complain they lack the proprietary tools and data to service many late-model cars. There are some 500,000 independent auto-repair shops in the U.S., industry figures show.


Many garage owners hope the new small-business-friendly tone in Washington, including sweeping regulatory reviews unveiled last month, will re-energize the Right to Repair Act, a bill they say levels the playing field with auto dealerships.


The bill, which in various forms has languished in Congress for nearly a decade, requires auto makers like Ford Motor Co., General Motors Co. and Toyota Motor Corp., to supply smaller repair shops with the same onboard-computer data they give to their affiliated dealerships. Technology in newer vehicles controls everything from the steering wheel to the fuel delivery system, brakes, air bags, tire pressure and more.


Supporters, including a range of auto-service-trade associations, consumer groups and small-business advocates, say the move will boost competition in the auto-repair market, forcing dealerships to lower prices.


Auto makers, who fiercely oppose the bill, say they need to protect trade secrets from cheap generic parts makers. The car makers say mechanics already have access to what they need to get vehicles back on the road.


Yet there appears to be some grass-roots support for the bill. A survey in November by AutoMD.com, an auto-repair-information website, found 83% of 2,800 car owners polled said they favored right-to-repair legislation. Supporters have shown up on Capitol Hill in jumpsuits and overalls to rally lawmakers to pass the measure.


Initially introduced by Rep. Joe Barton (R., Texas) just before the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, the bill was buried under a wave of national-security legislation. It has since been reintroduced in every federal legislative session, only to get bogged down amid strong lobbying by auto makers and dealers. The latest version was sponsored last year in the Senate by Sens. Barbara Boxer (D., Calif.) and Sam Brownback (R., Kan.), while a bill put forward two years earlier by Reps. Edolphus Towns (D., N.Y.), Anna Eshoo (D., Calif.) and George Miller (D., Calif.) had more than 60 co-sponsors, including high-ranking members from both parties. Both Sen. Boxer and Rep. Towns expect to reintroduce the bill as early as possible in the new session, with concessions aimed at easing auto makers' intellectual-property concerns, their spokespeople say.


But supporters say the bill may stand a better chance in states such as New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut—and in Kansas, where Mr. Brownback is now governor.


Last July, the bill passed the Massachusetts state senate only to collapse when the House closed its regular session—the closest its come anywhere to being enacted—after debate on a casino-licensing bill put all other issues on hold. State lawmakers there also expect to reintroduce the bill later this year.


"We think the momentum now is at the state level," says Aaron Lowe, vice president of regulatory and government affairs at the Automotive Aftermarket Industry Association, a Bethesda, Md.-based trade group that has lobbied for the bill since 2001. It estimates that repairs cost up to 34% more at dealerships than small repair shops, or an extra $11.7 billion spent by drivers on their cars every year. "Once it's adopted in one state, we expect it'll spread to others pretty quickly," he says.


Auto makers aren't going to let that happen without a fight. "The problem is they want full access to all the computer information, not just the repair codes but also the design and manufacturing codes. And that's where intellectual property kicks in," says Gloria Bergquist, a spokesperson for the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, a Washington advocacy group that represents Ford, GM, Toyota, Porsche and other auto makers. She says all the necessary tools and diagnostic data for any repair job are available online from individual auto makers, as well as from tool manufacturers like Snap-on Inc.


Mr. Lowe says mechanics aren't interested in auto makers' intellectual property.


"We don't want to know how to make their onboard computers. We want what's on those computers. That's what right-to-repair is all about," he says.


Beyond intellectual-property issues, Sandy Bass-Cors, executive director of the Coalition for Auto Repair Equality in Alexandria, Va., says mechanics are frustrated that the federal government spent billions of dollars bailing out GM and Chrysler during the recession, while boosting dealership sales with the Cash for Clunkers program.


"Yet they're keeping the same motoring taxpayers from having a choice in repairs," she says.


For now, Mr. Marconi says he's taking vehicles that need reprogramming to dealers himself, often at a loss, rather than send drivers away. "This is crazy," he says. "But in this economy the last thing you want to do is turn down a customer."



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Forum Topics

    • Goodyear exiting the repair business

      It seems that Goodyear corporate stores are changing their business model from Tire and Repair Service centers to strictly tires.   The franchise stores are free to continue their old business model.    Around here, the corporate stores are going to close down on January 27 for 2-3 weeks for a major remodel and possibly? rebranding.   They will sell tires and do alignments, but will not be able to align if they need repair parts.   I've not seen any official statements on this, so I don't really know more than the scuttlebutt. It looks like Hunter will have a great year this year as a result.  I saw a brand new Hunter Revolution tire machine in one of the local stores already. I stand to benefit from this change as we may see some of their repair business.   Since I don't sell tires, I'm not a Goodyear competitor, which allows them to safely refer repair business to us.   Almost everyone else around here sells tires.   We refer quite a few folks to tire-only stores, so Goodyear will now be on my referral list.

      By bantar, in General Automotive Discussion

      • 3 replies
    • Seeking/open to Partnership for Repair Shop Planning

      Hey All, My name is Karla, I had previously owned a 3-bay mechanical repair shop in Burlington, VT for 6 years and built it to maintain an outstanding reputation and provide a comfortable income. I had the opportunity to sell my half of the business and finalized that deal this past fall. I have worked in all areas of the auto repair industry over the past 15 years, graduated from a two-year ASE certified auto tech program and went on to earn my Bachelor’s in business and a masters degree in executive leadership.  I have some capital I will be contributing to the planning and opening of a new shop and am very open to meeting potential partners/investors in all areas of the country. I greatly look forward to building something new in a location new to me. Anyway, I’d like to welcome all /any interest and to answer any questions about joining forces in shop planning and management. Please do not hesitate to contact me, thanks for considering! —Karla

      By KDshopNEA, in Automotive Business Opportunities

      • 2 replies
    • Killer Holiday Tip for your repair shop

      Here's a tip I have posted before, but it's worth repeating.  One job that goes unnoticed most of the year is the job of the part's driver.  You get part deliveries all day long, every day, all year long.  Many times, these part's drivers take all the abuse due to wrong parts, the parts took too long to be delivered, on and on and on.  Those drivers may not say anything, but they take it to heart.  So, here's what you are going to do.  Buy small gifts, such as small boxes of candy or chocolate.  Nothing expensive.  During the holidays, give all the drivers one of these small gifts and say "Thank you, I appreciated what you do." Two things will happen. First, the driver will be stunned and will not know what to say, and they will be very thankful that you thought of them.  The second thing that will happen is this:  The very next time those part drivers have three delivers to make at three different shops, what shop do you think they will want to go to first?  Yes...Yours!  

      By Joe Marconi, in Joe’s Business Tips For Shop Owners

      • 2 replies
    • identafix direct shop migrate

      hello everyone just started here .i just got signup with identafix and direct shop i need to migrate my mitchell teamwork to identafix direct shop.the sales person at identafix lied to me he said they can migrate it .then i find out they want 600.00 they are out of there minds lol

      By r & l auto service, in Auto Repair Shop Management Help? Post Here!

      • 0 replies
    • Free Simple Shop Management Software

      Hey Everyone, I'm Ricardo from Complete Auto Reports.  You may have heard about the shop management software that we made at a shop in Linden NJ.  We've been really busy over the last year trying to refine the process at a shop through the software.  We have come up with something we think that people can and will benefit from.  We want to start with smaller auto repair facilities who are looking for something to transition out of paper and pen, as well as word documents and/or excel spreadsheets.   We've taken our software and made a free package that allows the following from any device with a updated and functional browser: Take appointments from your customers Digital Vehicle Inspections - Included in every service request and sent to each customer if performed Workflow - Pending, Under Process, Awaiting Approval, Approval Completed, Work In Progress, Completed Ratings - Customers can communicate ratings directly to you Messages - You can communicate with customers through the platform Customer App - All service history available, can schedule appointments with the app, transfer vehicle records to new owners Sales Reports 100% mobile - Works on everything from your 5inch iPhone to your desktop.  You can presently upload all of your customer information: name, address, phone numbers, email. Paid for versions offer parts ordering through PartsTech.com and Employeement modules that track employee time on jobs. Are there members here who are interested in trying the free platform to see if it's a fit for their business? Anyone interested in the paid for versions, can also get 60 days of free use and discounted rates available from our SEMA promotions.

      By CAR_AutoReports, in Management Software, Web Sites & Internet

      • 4 replies
  • AutoShopOwner Sponsors