Quantcast
Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I own/run a truck, diesel and offroad performance shop. I have been paying strictly by the hour, but its really not working out. I want to be able to pay my guys better but I cant afford to be hung out to dry on the hours. I have been reading on this forum about flat rate and a performance bonus, I really like the concept, it will keep me in the black and my guys can make more money. I am just not sure how to accomplish this for my business. We do alot of high performance work that requires more than one tech to accomplish. How do you pay? I cant charge the customer double time to make up the difference and I want to be fair to my guys, but on the other hand I have to make a profit also.

So my question is this;

 

1 How do you come up with a fair number to pay on the flat rate?

2 How do I split the job between the two techs, without going broke?

3 What do you base the percentage on to come up with a performance bonus?

 

I welcome any and all input to these questions. I need some answers quickly, before I lose one of my best techs to another store. He wants more money, I want to pay him more he is definitely worth it, but increasing his pay scale by-the-hour is killing my profit margin. I know that flat rate is th way to go...

 

JOE

Posted

The issue with splitting tech time must be accounted for properly. Accurate time keepping and record keepping procedures must be designed. If you estimate that a job will take 6 hours and you put two techs on a job, each portion of the job must be broken down into segments of the job. It's not easy at times, but you need to be fair to the customer and fair to the techs. Once the job is broken down, you need to assign the time properly in your managment system. We use Mitchell. In Mitchell you can divide the labor time among many techs and the hours can be split any way you need to. What system to use you? So, splitting the tech hours should not impact the business in any way.

 

As far as performance bonues are concerned, I would first track everyone's hours for a least a month. I would also make sure you review your Cost Of Doing Business numbers, to know your breakeven and what you need above breakeven. Also, make sure you track gross profit dollars. Basing bonues just on sales or booked hours is not the best way. Find out at what point the shop is making money and base the bonus on this number.

Posted

The issue with splitting tech time must be accounted for properly. Accurate time keepping and record keepping procedures must be designed. If you estimate that a job will take 6 hours and you put two techs on a job, each portion of the job must be broken down into segments of the job. It's not easy at times, but you need to be fair to the customer and fair to the techs. Once the job is broken down, you need to assign the time properly in your managment system. We use Mitchell. In Mitchell you can divide the labor time among many techs and the hours can be split any way you need to. What system to use you? So, splitting the tech hours should not impact the business in any way.

 

As far as performance bonues are concerned, I would first track everyone's hours for a least a month. I would also make sure you review your Cost Of Doing Business numbers, to know your breakeven and what you need above breakeven. Also, make sure you track gross profit dollars. Basing bonues just on sales or booked hours is not the best way. Find out at what point the shop is making money and base the bonus on this number.

 

Well I tried BBT software but I could never get it to work properly. I have heard of Mitchell, is it expensive? Right now I have access to ALL DATA, so thats what I use to set our labor rate. I also use Labor Guide to check the numbers.

 

Any input on the first question? I have heard numbers from 22.00-29.99 per flag hour fare these about right or too high/low?

Posted

Well I tried BBT software but I could never get it to work properly. I have heard of Mitchell, is it expensive? Right now I have access to ALL DATA, so thats what I use to set our labor rate. I also use Labor Guide to check the numbers.

 

Any input on the first question? I have heard numbers from 22.00-29.99 per flag hour fare these about right or too high/low?

 

Mitchell is very resonably priced. It depends on how many stations you want also. You should speak to a rep for more information.

 

As far as flagged flat rate hours, there are so many ways to skin this cat. Some shop owners pay the tech a gurantee hourly base, any where from 30 to 40 hours. Then, if they hit a predetermined productivity number, they get a bonus for every hour above that. There are many formulas you can use.

 

Again, you should track each tech for a month or so, find out how productive they are. Then after you know this, calculate how much you need to book in order to acheive for sales goals and profit goals. This way you are not just coming up with someone else's numbers. This will insure that you are paying bonus and payroll on what the shop earns in profit.

 

As far as how much to pay...well that's hard to say. It depends on the quality of the tech, the expereince, etc. Plus, many shops pay on a sliding scale. For example, for the first 40 hrs booked, the tech gets $20.00 per hour. Over 40 to 45, the tech may get $24.00 per hr. On and On.

 

I can tell you that in my area good A techs are earning anywhere from $20.00 to above $30.00 per hr, before bonus.

 

I know one shop owner that pays straight time to 40 hrs booked (in a 40hr work week) and time and half for anything booked over 40 hrs.

 

It also depends on you labor rate and how effecient your shop is and how effecient your shop is at selling profitable repairs. Also, how the tickets are written.

 

It gets kind of complicated. I hope I did not cloud the issue, but as you can see, there's a lot to consider when setting up a pay plan.

Posted

Mitchell is very resonably priced. It depends on how many stations you want also. You should speak to a rep for more information.

 

As far as flagged flat rate hours, there are so many ways to skin this cat. Some shop owners pay the tech a gurantee hourly base, any where from 30 to 40 hours. Then, if they hit a predetermined productivity number, they get a bonus for every hour above that. There are many formulas you can use.

 

Again, you should track each tech for a month or so, find out how productive they are. Then after you know this, calculate how much you need to book in order to acheive for sales goals and profit goals. This way you are not just coming up with someone else's numbers. This will insure that you are paying bonus and payroll on what the shop earns in profit.

 

As far as how much to pay...well that's hard to say. It depends on the quality of the tech, the expereince, etc. Plus, many shops pay on a sliding scale. For example, for the first 40 hrs booked, the tech gets $20.00 per hour. Over 40 to 45, the tech may get $24.00 per hr. On and On.

 

I can tell you that in my area good A techs are earning anywhere from $20.00 to above $30.00 per hr, before bonus.

 

I know one shop owner that pays straight time to 40 hrs booked (in a 40hr work week) and time and half for anything booked over 40 hrs.

 

It also depends on you labor rate and how effecient your shop is and how effecient your shop is at selling profitable repairs. Also, how the tickets are written.

 

It gets kind of complicated. I hope I did not cloud the issue, but as you can see, there's a lot to consider when setting up a pay plan.

 

Man you aint lying there, that gives me a headache just trying to decipher all that information. But I have to do it so I can get my life back. I started this business with a dream and so far that dream is a nightmare...LOL I owned a cabinet shop before doing this for 20 years,(I know you are now asking yourself what an I doing in this business) did pretty good, 15 employees at one time, running two jobs at once or more all over the state. So I do understand what you are saying its just a bit more complicated than before, but I will figure it out, with you guy's help. Thanks so much for all the advice.

JOE

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Available Subscriptions

  • Have you checked out Joe's Latest Blog?

         0 comments
      It always amazes me when I hear about a technician who quits one repair shop to go work at another shop for less money. I know you have heard of this too, and you’ve probably asked yourself, “Can this be true? And Why?” The answer rests within the culture of the company. More specifically, the boss, manager, or a toxic work environment literally pushed the technician out the door.
      While money and benefits tend to attract people to a company, it won’t keep them there. When a technician begins to look over the fence for greener grass, that is usually a sign that something is wrong within the workplace. It also means that his or her heart is probably already gone. If the issue is not resolved, no amount of money will keep that technician for the long term. The heart is always the first to leave. The last thing that leaves is the technician’s toolbox.
      Shop owners: Focus more on employee retention than acquisition. This is not to say that you should not be constantly recruiting. You should. What it does means is that once you hire someone, your job isn’t over, that’s when it begins. Get to know your technicians. Build strong relationships. Have frequent one-on-ones. Engage in meaningful conversation. Find what truly motivates your technicians. You may be surprised that while money is a motivator, it’s usually not the prime motivator.
      One last thing; the cost of technician turnover can be financially devastating. It also affects shop morale. Do all you can to create a workplace where technicians feel they are respected, recognized, and know that their work contributes to the overall success of the company. This will lead to improved morale and team spirit. Remember, when you see a technician’s toolbox rolling out of the bay on its way to another shop, the heart was most likely gone long before that.
  • Similar Topics

    • By MikesPlaceAuto
      Hello from Montana. Longtime mechanic/technician, first-time shop owner. Reaching out to many sources for information and advice. Small shop in rural setting, specializing in electrical and electronics. Thanks for any good words. Mike
    • By Changing The Industry
      Episode 216 - Can You Achieve High Performance Through Coaching with Cecil Bullard and Michael Smith
    • By nptrb
      Running an auto repair shop comes with a unique set of challenges, and managing your finances is a big one. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to scale, understanding cash flow management for auto repair shops is crucial to your long-term success.
      In this post, we’re sharing practical, actionable strategies to help you take control of your shop’s finances and boost your auto repair business profitability—without sacrificing service quality or customer trust.
      What Is Cash Flow and Why Is It Important?
      Cash flow refers to the money moving in and out of your business. 
      For small businesses like yours, positive cash flow ensures that you can pay your team, keep parts in stock, handle operating costs, and still have something left to reinvest in growth.
      When cash flow gets tight, it affects everything—from your ability to take on more jobs to your peace of mind. That’s why improving cash flow in small businesses, especially in the auto repair industry, is one of the smartest moves you can make.
      Common Financial Challenges Auto Repair Shops Face
      Auto repair shops often experience:
      Slow payments from customers or insurance companies High up-front costs for tools, equipment, and parts Seasonal dips in customer volume Discounting services too frequently Recognizing these patterns is the first step toward smarter cash flow management in your business.
      5 Financial Tips to Improve Cash Flow
      Here are some real-world auto repair shop financial tips you can start implementing today:
      Streamline Your Invoicing and Payments
      Make it easy for customers to pay by offering digital invoicing and online payment options. Send invoices quickly, and set up automated reminders. 
      The faster you get paid, the better your cash flow.
      Review Your Pricing Structure
      If your rates haven’t changed in a while, it might be time for a tune-up. 
      Make sure your pricing reflects the value you provide while also supporting your auto repair business’s profitability.
      Manage Inventory and Ordering
      Don’t let cash get stuck on your shelves. Track what parts you actually use and only stock what’s necessary. Consider just-in-time ordering to reduce overhead.
      Reduce Unnecessary Expenses
      Look closely at your subscriptions, software, utilities, and vendor costs. Managing expenses in auto repair shops doesn’t have to mean cutting corners—just being more intentional with your spending.
      Create Consistent Revenue Streams
      Prepaid service packages, maintenance memberships, or seasonal promotions can help bring in predictable income, smoothing out your cash flow during slow periods. 
      With summer coming, now is a great time to offer deals on tune-ups for people who will be traveling!
      Forecasting = Fewer Surprises
      Cash flow forecasting allows you to plan for upcoming expenses and income. This helps you avoid financial surprises and confidently make big decisions—like hiring another tech or investing in new equipment.
      Even small adjustments in how you manage your shop’s finances can have a big impact over time. Staying proactive and strategic helps ensure your shop is profitable, sustainable, and ready to grow.
      Taking control of your finances starts with understanding your numbers and making small, consistent changes. By focusing on cash flow management for auto repair shops and applying smart financial tips tailored to your industry, you’ll be in a much stronger position to weather the ups and downs of your business.
    • By stevefry
      I have a client looking to sell their Auto Body Shop in Monteagle TN called Lakeside Collision. He is asking $1,500,000 and the property did a little over $1,200,000 last year. Profitable business with lots of equipment and inventory, newer paint booth and includes 2 lots and 2 buildings with 8 bay doors.
      Also have another client looking for an Auto Body business to purchase in Davidson County (Nashville) TN. Looking for a shop with the business and the real estate. 
    • By Joe Marconi
      Over the weekend I met a 67 year old shop owner who has been in business for 41 years, and still involved in the day to day operations. He added that he has done nothing to plan for his future and his exit. 
      Life can throw us a curve ball at any age, are your properly prepared.
      I know it sounds a little crazy, but the right time to get you business ready to sell, is when you first go into business.
      What are you doing to prepare for your exit, sale or if life throws you a curve ball?
       
       


  • Our Sponsors

×
×
  • Create New...