Never heard of Lighthouse but YODLE sucks. Used them several years ago and my directory listings are still jacked up, even with extensive time trying to correct and using a paid service. Currently using YEXT. They're ok. Pretty easy to use dashboard/interface. Been with them just over a year. Most directory listings are now correct. It's a Catch 22. There are very few free directory listings anymore. Posting corrections and updates can be very time consuming. So services like YEXT are helpful. The best I understand they don't actually claim the listing but are partnered with directories and do post updates. If you ever terminate service you run the risk of the directories reverting to incorrect info. At this point, I'm staying with YEXT until I figure a better way. I do know that it is imperative for all your address/contact/location information be consistent across all directories and listings or you risk getting scattered in lower rankings. Just looked up Lighthouse. It's a Yodle app. Me personally, I will not even explore it further because it's Yodle. I would be VERY hesitant about giving Yodle any access to your customer and service data.