Quantcast

Jump to content



Shop Owners Sign Up FREE!
Are you an automotive shop owner or manager looking to network with others in your industry? Don't wait any longer, click this box and sign up to start networking today!
Photo

What's Your Favorite Scan Tool


  • Please log in to reply
45 replies to this topic

#21 Joe Marconi

Joe Marconi

    ASO Staff Member

  • ASO Staff Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,984 posts
  • Osceola Garage
  • Baldwin Place, ny

We have a SnapOn Verus & an older version of Vantage(use it mostly for multimeter function), & a basic OBD2 scan tool. Traded in our Modis to get the Verus. The thing about SnapOn is they never have had any support for Volvo or Saab. We do work on a few of them but not enough to buy a specialized tool just for them.
The thing I like best about the Verus is that it's a combination scanner/lab scope/ignition analyzer and laptop computer. Can store all information for each car we scan in it. Pretty good tool.


We have the Snap On Solis, would you say the Versus is a step up from the Solis?

#22 Richard

Richard

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 10 posts
  • Ingham& Sons Automotive Service
  • Punxsutawney, pa
The Verus is a step up from the Modis. The Modis combines the scanner features of the Solis with the lab scope/multimeter features of the Vantage. So I would say the next step up from the Solis would be the Modis.

Edited by Richard, March 19, 2010 - 08:49 PM.


#23 HTI.WERKSTATT

HTI.WERKSTATT

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 31 posts
  • HTI WERKSTATT
  • Dayton, oh
Well guys I'm personally biting the bullet... Just picked up a Snap-On Verus w/ Euro package for 7,700.00 brand new... Will have it here at the shop in a couple weeks. And give you guys an update on how well it works out.

#24 Brianp

Brianp

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 90 posts
  • Phillips Auto Repair
  • Cottonwood, az
I have a mastertech,vci and a modis. The modis is the best universal we have. I would like oe but they are changing so much recently I cant bite that bullet until they all settle on one for a bit.

#25 Gonzo

Gonzo

    Expert Member

  • Publishers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,233 posts
  • Superior Auto Electric
  • Tulsa, ok
Dealer level scanners... without a doubt.
Tech 2, NGS, IDS, DRB
I use a MasterTech for most everything for quick code reads or mode 6 info. The MasterTech can do a lot, some programming and some air bag reset stuff. Nice scanner.
GM - ya gotta have a Tech 2 easy to read, easy to understand... sometimes hard to navigate thru the maze of info... but very, very good
NGS - a little dated, but easy to use. Good PID sections... wish it had a misfire graph like the Tech 2... I'll use the O2 PID along with the injector pulse readings to determine misfires.
IDS - expensive... nice, takes a little practice to work it... nice though
DRB - another dated machine... farely easy... Up to 05 it's effective... after that... sorry

I've looked at the Snap-on machines... sorry guys, not impressed. To many cords, clips, and small parts. The info is somewhat sketchy... on all models.

I guess the best way to put it is... The customer wants it fixed... they don't care how ya do it...as long as it's cheap. So if you have the wrong scanner or not enough info incorporated into that scanner... you're screwed...

I think of scanners like this.... They give you a rope, a tree, and a three legged horse... "You've got almost all the info you need, but some scanners will leave just that last little bit out... and sure enough that horse is going to hang ya... "
\

Taking a poll. Let me know your favorite scan tool or tools. Most of us work on just about what ever rolls thru the bay doors. That can be an issue.



#26 Brianp

Brianp

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 90 posts
  • Phillips Auto Repair
  • Cottonwood, az
I agree oem is the way to go but tech 2, drb and ids are not current any longer. They are all switching to vci format (laptop based). I like the idea one laptop and many vci modules. To bad bosch cant make there vci work. Im in a wait mode right now as to which one to get next.

#27 Gonzo

Gonzo

    Expert Member

  • Publishers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,233 posts
  • Superior Auto Electric
  • Tulsa, ok
Totally agree with ya. As a matter of fact, I wrote an article about using the J2534 (crap)... not impressed... If I was in a push/shove delimea... I think I would try ... but honestly... I'd go with the OEM.
The VCI modules is the latest greatest... But I'm sure that will all change in a bit too.
My Tech 2 gets a work out around here. But so does the IDS... I hardly pull the NGS out these days, but it's nice to have.
The DRB is really only there for reprogramming and or HVAC solutions. (very dated)

Thanx for your insight... you're right on the money... Gonzo

I agree oem is the way to go but tech 2, drb and ids are not current any longer. They are all switching to vci format (laptop based). I like the idea one laptop and many vci modules. To bad bosch cant make there vci work. Im in a wait mode right now as to which one to get next.



#28 Junior

Junior

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 45 posts
  • Woodstock Automotive
  • Woodstock, ny
We use a Snap-On Verus with every option, topped around $8k for it and I would not recommend it at all. The development of snap-on electrical tools and the feedback to their development staff is terrible. We are now on our 3rd brand new unit, a dozen or so software updates and the tool still does not work as it should. There are lots of bugs in the way the program works and snap-on support has no way of getting these problems fixed when you call the tech line to report them. I have gone through a handful of contacts with snap-on diagnostics all of them give terrible feedback. The new update to 10.4 software brought countless bugs. The system simply isn't stable and in many cases simply does not work. The scope leaves much to be desired too. Sampling rate and display response of the scope is terribly slow. Options to configure triggers often do not work. I've had issues where I couldn't do something simple like scope an injector. Even had the snap-on tech guy here and left him with the car for a whole afternoon and they couldn't get it to work. I pulled out my old bluepoint scope on an extension cord (batteries are no longer available or I'd still use this thing) and had a waveform in less than a minute. We also bought the low amp probe for the Verus, it doesn't work at all. It will read up to a half amp draw if you just wave the thing around in the air. Still waiting on a replacement for that, its been a month.

The tool is far to expensive for its shortcomings and as the main tool used in our shop it can grind work to a stop when it fails which is at least weekly. We do a lot of VW/Audi work and I have a Ross-Tech for that. I also have the German package for the Verus but it will crash every time you're in expert mode, making it entirely useless. Luckily I can use the Ross-Tech as a OBD-II generic tool which helps a lot as a backup to the Verus. We are unfortunately already heavily invested in snap-on diagnostic equipment but will never buy anything from them again. The hand tools I think are generally worth the premium price but the diagnostic tools are not nearly worth the money and simply do not work as advertised.

#29 scantoolnut

scantoolnut

    Browsing Member

  • Free Members
  • 5 posts
  • Raio's Repair
  • Westfield, nj
I am not a Snap-On fans. If you want a good overall scan tool that has scope and gas analyzer, the OTC Genesys is the most cost effective. We are also very happy with Auto Enginuity, which is the best Euro scan tool we used aside from the Autologic (which is the Bugatti of scan tools.) The Auto Enginuity is the best bang for your buck by far, it is very good on US and Euro, not as much on Asian (though it is just behind Launch or Carman Scan on Asian.)



On youtube there was a good scan tool shoot out on VW that gets into the real-world specifics of what these tools do. It goes along with what I know from real world experience.

#30 CARMandP

CARMandP

    Contributing Member

  • Free Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 596 posts
  • CAR Maintenance and Performance
  • , tn
I have the Auto Enginuity and really haven't been happy with it. It doesn't have the testing functions that I think it should. When you use that scanner for Ford it has all the output tests but Chevy it doesn't offer it? Either that or I don't know how to use it well enough and the info it came with is pretty much useless.

#31 scantoolnut

scantoolnut

    Browsing Member

  • Free Members
  • 5 posts
  • Raio's Repair
  • Westfield, nj

I have the Auto Enginuity and really haven't been happy with it. It doesn't have the testing functions that I think it should. When you use that scanner for Ford it has all the output tests but Chevy it doesn't offer it? Either that or I don't know how to use it well enough and the info it came with is pretty much useless.

The AE is not user friendly at all. It hides bi directionals under the name "activation tests" that you need to side click on to get. For VW, it uses a totally different terminology and process to access the same thing. Real stupid.

But, the functionality is there and that's what I care about.

#32 Junior

Junior

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 45 posts
  • Woodstock Automotive
  • Woodstock, ny
I just took a look at a Bosch KTS 340 yesterday. The tools looks pretty good, european coverage is tremendously better than the Verus, Asian coverage looks very good too. The rep said that they are a little behind in GM coverage, primarily since they also sell the Tech2 specifically for GM. I guess the GM software (old vetronix) iis being merged with the Bosch software on the KTS line over the next year, at least that was the salesman's pitch. Is anyone using the Bosch tools. It runs linux and is significantly faster than the verus. I didn't have time to get into that many cars. We are thinking about selling our Verus and might get into this tool or another like it. The Verus is just to many headaches, especially for the ultimate premium price tag we spent on it.

#33 Brianp

Brianp

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 90 posts
  • Phillips Auto Repair
  • Cottonwood, az
I use bosch and like the master tech(have had a few) and the lab scope(have had a few also) but I have the new vci and they cannot get it to work right and are offerign little to no assistance. Im not pleased with there help. I would makeit a point to bring it up to your rep. Our rep is not good. He tells me just to use mine plugged in? I bought it cause its wireless? Good luck.

#34 blown3qtr

blown3qtr

    Browsing Member

  • Free Members
  • 6 posts
  • none
  • , TX
I use the OTC Genysis and find it OK. It does most of what I need. Some bidirectional controls. At times it is VERY slow to update PIDs, seconds behind what the sensors are actually reading. I have even reverted to my cheap autoxray for faster response at times. I miss the TechII from the dealer. I am always looking for something bigger, better, and more bang for the buck. The Autoenginuity seems very appealing.

#35 ATLAuto

ATLAuto

    Advanced Member

  • Free Members
  • PipPip
  • 208 posts
  • AA
  • Atlanta, ga

All domestics and asian imports. I also have a Volkswagen kicking my butt right now as well.


I've had some good success with the VAG-COM for VW and Audi. Cost me $200 a few years ago and hooks into a laptop USB port. Great software. Does just about everything the factory tool does for WAY cheaper. http://www.ross-tech.com/

#36 Zs Automotive

Zs Automotive

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 18 posts
  • Zs Automotive
  • Hubert, nc
I currently use the Hanatech Ultra scan, for the price I'm pretty impressed cost around 3800 has a wide coverage of vehicle, very fast and has good bidirectional control, updates are not expensive, free for two years. Of course is not perfect the o-scope I don't like it us not color screen not self powered. Has anyone else played with this scan tool?

#37 5 Star Auto Spa

5 Star Auto Spa

    Advanced Member

  • Free Members
  • PipPip
  • 117 posts
  • 5 Star Auto Spa
  • Winchester, va

I've heard GREAT things about the Hanatech Ultra Scan BUT as of January 1 2014, Hanatech will no longer be offering updates for their Ultrascan and Multi-scan units.  FYI



#38 Zs Automotive

Zs Automotive

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 18 posts
  • Zs Automotive
  • Hubert, nc
According to the us rep I deal with, updates are not going away. Where did you find this info. Thanks

#39 mspecperformance

mspecperformance

    Advanced Member

  • Free Members
  • PipPip
  • 416 posts
  • M-Spec Performance
  • Middle Village, ny

What I find lacking is the speed of a lot of scan tools. We have an Autel that we use to scan everything other than Euros. We use a VAG Com for Audi/Volkswagen and autologic for BMW and mercedes. The autologic has fast boot up times, it take a few minutes to set the lap top up and the autel is SLOWWW.



#40 Dustin Rutkowski

Dustin Rutkowski

    Posting Member

  • Free Members
  • Pip
  • 56 posts
  • Auto Dr LLC
  • Ira Township, mi

Verus pro is what we use and like.  Does just about everything we need.  Also have an OTC Genisys for when the Verus is in use. 








0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users